This analysis seeks to characterize diagnostic error in the preoperative, intraoperative, and postoperative surgical phases, describe their contributing factors, and quantify their impact related to patient harm.
Characteristics and contributing factors of diagnostic error in surgery: Analysis of closed medico-legal cases and complaints in Canada
Abstract
Background: Diagnostic errors lead to significant patient harm; however, most research has been conducted in non-surgical disciplines. We sought to characterize diagnostic error in the pre-, intra-, and post-operative surgical phases, describe their contributing factors, and quantify their impact related to patient harm.
Methods: We performed a retrospective analysis of closed medico-legal cases and complaints using a database representing over 95% of all Canadian physicians. We included cases if they involved a legal action or complaint that closed between 2014 and 2018 and involved a diagnostic error assigned by peer expert review to a surgeon.
Results: We identified 387 surgical cases that involved a diagnostic error. The surgical specialties most often associated with diagnostic error were general surgery (n = 151, 39.0%), gynecology (n = 71, 18.3%), and orthopedic surgery (n = 48, 12.4%), but most surgical specialties were represented. Errors occurred more often in the postoperative phase (n = 171, 44.2%) than in the pre- (n = 127, 32.8%) or intra-operative (n = 120, 31.0%) phases of surgical care. More than 80% of the contributing factors for diagnostic errors were related to providers, with clinical decision-making being the principal contributing factor. Half of the contributing factors were related to the health care team (n = 194, 50.1%), the most common of which was communication breakdown. More than half of patients involved in a surgical diagnostic error experienced at least moderate harm, with 1 in 7 cases resulting in death.
Conclusions: In our cohort, diagnostic errors occurred in most surgical disciplines and across all surgical phases of care; contributing factors were commonly attributed to provider clinical decision-making and communication breakdown. Surgical patient safety efforts should include diagnostic errors with a focus on understanding and reducing errors in surgical clinical decision-making and improving communication.
Reference
Kwan JL, Calder LA, Bowman CL, MacIntyre A, Mimeault R, Honey L, Dunn C, Garber G, Singh H. Characteristics and contributing factors of diagnostic error in surgery: Analysis of closed medico-legal cases and complaints in Canada. Canadian Journal of Surgery [Internet]. 2024 February 6, 67 (1) E58-E65. doi: 10.1503/cjs.003523
